Pass Notes: R U a trendy teacher?

It’s Friday afternoon at the newly opened Bash Street Academy, and Teacher, re-invigourated by the inspirational leadership and direction of nice Mr Gove, is bravely attempting to teach 11B the finer points of the now government-required Marcel Proust’s ‘À la recherche du temps perdu‘ (In Search of Lost Time; earlier translated as Remembrance of Things Past).

Sir, Sir!

Yes, what is it?

Are you a trendy teacher?

Well yes, I suppose I like to think so – hence my kipper tie and flared trousers, in case you hadn’t noticed. And I still like to listen to my Beatles LPs. Why do you ask?

Well it says here that Mr Gove wants to get rid of ‘wild and wacky’ trendy teachers. So does that mean you’ll be retiring soon Sir?

Ah. Hmmm – you’ve been reading the Daily Mail again haven’t you? I’ve warned you about doing that before – it will make you go blind you know…

Well Sir, there’s one of those quizzes here to help you discover if you are a trendy teacher or not*. So first question:

1. Do you:
a) adopt an anti-intellectual and anti-acquisition of knowledge approach in the classroom, and see teaching as a two-way process, or
b) know you are in the classroom to teach, and that children are there to acquire your knowledge, with the emphasis on the memorisation and recall of facts and figures?

2. Do you:
a) teach mainly through themes such as global citizenship, saving the planet, and through role-play and popular works of fiction, or
b) teach geography and history as it is written, straight from the textbook?

3. Do you:
a) refer to texts that are relevant to pupils’ everyday experiences, or
b) teach Milton, Spencer and Pope, even though no-one is listening?

4. Do you:
a) encourage child-led lessons with no assessment or testing, with children only learning when they feel like it, or
b) don’t teach anything that can’t be formally and scientifically assessed, and heavily criticise failure.

5. Do you:
a) use eccentric teaching methods, giving pupils a choice of tasks, asking them questions rather than giving answers, and encouraging them to find things out for themselves, or:
b) use one teaching method all the time that is inappropriate for most pupils, always giving them factual answers and telling them exactly what they must do, and when?

6. Do you:
a) teach open-ended lessons that lack stimulus and challenge within an inconsistent and incoherent structure, or
b) teach highly structured academic-led lessons that lack stimulus and challenge for the vast majority of pupils?

7. Did you:
a) attend a left-wing teacher-training college rooted in discredited ideological 1960s folly, opposed to disciplined teaching, or
b) fail to gain a place on a left-wing teacher-training college rooted in discredited ideological 1960s folly, opposed to disciplined teaching?

8. Do you:
a) send forth vast numbers of children unfit to participate in the life of our society, or
b) send forth vast numbers of children only able to fail to become university professors?

9. Do you believe all parents want their children to:
a) be happy, discover and develop their individual talents and abilities, be socially confident and capable of obtaining life-long employment as an adult, or
b) have proper traditional school uniforms, strict discipline, and be taught academic subjects rigorously?

10. Do you allow pupils to distract you during lessons asking right-wing biased quizzes about teachers?
Only answer a) Yes, if you have got this far.

So how did you do Sir?  If you answered mainly a) then apparently you are ‘ just one of tens of thousands of wild and wacky teachers unfit to be in the classroom, you spend your time clamouring for more and more cash, and resist reform ‘.  If you answered mainly b), you ‘use tried and tested (or as your pupils see it, tired and detested) teaching methods. You probably retired from teaching some 30 years ago and were previously in the armed forces. However you are still in line for the ‘Nice Mr Gove Teacher of the Year’ award. You read the Daily Mail every day and believe every word of it without question‘.

Well, I would have to say I answered a mixture of a)s and b)s. However the quiz questions seem to have been compiled from a source that is clearly very ill-informed about teaching and learning and what goes on in most classrooms. In all my many years in the profession I can’t say I’ve ever met a teacher who would have answered yes to the majority of either sets of options. Most teaching involves an appropriate and sensible balance of formality and child-centered approaches.  But what’s most worrying is the inaccuracy of the messages that the general public are being given about what the vast majority of schools are like. It’s also a shame that in response, the education profession don’t seem to be able give a more positive account of themselves to the media.

Right, homework for tonight – whether you feel like doing it or not. In the ‘Leave a Comment’ box below describe three examples of things that we had in the 1950s that would be better if we went back to today – for example; ration books, logarithm tables and Teddy boys. No opinions of course – just stick to the facts. And the boy who gets the top mark will have the opportunity to go to Oxbridge – that is if he can afford the fees.


*OK, I made the quiz up, but based almost entirely on so-called facts and figures obtained from the following sources:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/educationnews/8013973/Michael-Goves-attack-on-wild-and-wacky-teaching.html

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-1296126/Ideologues-illiteracy-MAX-HASTINGS-terrible-damage-wrought-schools-Left-wing-educationalists.html#ixzz15vVK1pdr

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-1296126/Ideologues-illiteracy-MAX-HASTINGS-terrible-damage-wrought-schools-Left-wing-educationalists.html#ixzz15vVwyD43

Don’t say: ‘Go back to your classrooms and prepare for the 1950s.’

Do say: ‘So who exactly is this Max Hastings and how come he thinks he’s such an expert on education?’

3 comments on “Pass Notes: R U a trendy teacher?

  1. I was only 2 at the end of the 50s so don’t have any of my own memories but have just asked my Mum ans she said…. 1)The fact that there was no central heating and typically only one room in the house was ever warm meant that the family spent more time together as a unit. 2)That few people had cars meaning that not only was public transport more available but grown ups and young people were out together into the evening and night making the streets much safer and social places. 3) And credit was seriously frowned upon meaning that everyone understood deferred gratification and enjoyed saving up for things. PS If I win and could find the money I can’t think of much worse than having to go to Oxbridge – Scumbag uni for me every time!

  2. I was 0 in 1960 but my three things would be:

    1. Community spirit/cohesiveness: Everyone knew who you were, neighbours knew each other. Extended families were generally local, kids could do errands to the corner shops for Granddad’s tobacco and Grandma’s Gin. Your mum and dad would find out if you’d been up to no good!

    2. Getting warm: The fun of trimming the wick on the paraffin heater, stoking the fire, collecting the coals, chopping the wood, warming the milk and cocoa when you get in from the cold.

    3. Lack of things: Not having a million labour-saving devices, gadgets, toys, objects and pointless gifts that take up so much time and effort. The lack of day-to-day clutter and objects that now fill our houses almost seems desirable now. I wonder what I’d do without all today’s objects that fill my time. From calculators to the Internet, from Radiograms to MP3 players, from one set of basic clothes to wardrobes full of stuff I might wear again one day. Where does it end?

  3. Good things about the 50s:

    Knowing what I was expected to achieve.

    Bad things about the 50s:

    Knowing what I was expected to achieve.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s