Fact or Fiction?

It seems like that naughty Mr Gove has been talking out of turn again, displaying his profound and worrying lack of knowledge about the facts of education. In his most recent speech he stated as facts that racial minorities are disadvantaged by internal assessment, you can’t be creative unless you know everything there is to know, and that tests make you happy.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2012/nov/14/michael-gove-backs-learning-by-rote

Elsewhere it was reported that, in response to a statement by Sir James Dyson that too many teenagers were studying the lives of French lesbian poets at university,  Mad King Gove wittily retorted that Sir James was an example of the sort of anti-intellectual strain that was currently pervading British culture, cleverly revealing his complete ignorance of the way in which the new products and services we urgently need are created.

The first fact that needs questioning is the extent to which racial minorities are disadvantaged by teachers when marking coursework. There does not appear to be any clear evidence to support this statement, and most teachers would point to examples of racial minorities often scoring more highly than male white children. It is anyway also in teachers’ interests to mark absolutely all children up, rather than down, and quite reasonably, if inaccurately,assume that the moderation process will make the result fair in comparison to national standards.

But the main concern is Gove’s clear lack of understanding of creativity. To suggest that one can only be creative after one has learnt all the facts is a popular misconception of those who have little awareness of the process,  as anyone who has observed the creativity of primary school children and compared it to the narrowness of thought of secondary school students will confirm.  If anything, the reverse is true – it is creative thinking and exploration that leads  children to want to acquire knowledge. 

And finally there is the absurd propaganda about passing examinations making children feel happy and raising their self-esteem. Of course it does, but what about the larger,  non-academically orientated majority that is left feeling inadequate failures? At the same time, Gove needs to produce some evidence to support his curious belief that if you make an exam harder, significantly more students will pass.

But perhaps what is most worrying is that for all his private school and Oxbridge education, Gove has yet to realise that in reality there are of course no such things as facts, just commonly believed and accepted notions that are in a state of constant,and increasingly rapidly, change. 

Now, is that a fact?

One comment on “Fact or Fiction?

  1. These are all very good points, I challenge Mr Gove to answer them and a hundred others like them. His mistakes in understanding the world are just so childish in attitude.

    For all his eloquence and debating skills, this man’s failing is that he seems to think that it’s acceptable to enforce his own narrow views and beliefs on everyone else while actually rebuffing and rejecting the views of highly regarded public figures and bodies as well as almost every teacher, parent and child.

    He is also renowned for interpreting data in his own particular way, data that has either been proved wrong, out of context, or shown to have been misinterpreted by him, yet he doesn’t adjust his course or policies to take that correction into account.

    On a different tack, I find what he says to be so utterly offensive. He doesn’t charm or convince me at all, just about anything he says seems to be so out of touch with reality.

    It would be a hard job to prove he’s fair and right in his comments and actions. Does his position in government really give him so much blustering decisive power in a democracy? I thought he was there to steer a sensible course and react with what people suggest and advise, not to push on regardless with his personal beliefs against all his proven errors and misjudgements, taking into account the consensus of ‘common sense’ and showing respect for other’s views?

    What Mr Gove is doing is not right at all.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s